Title: Sfumato (4/? - Sequel to "The Marionette Rebellion") Author: supernova Disclaimer: Not mine; don't sue. Rating: R Category: MSR, Angst-O-Rama Archive: Not this time. Other than Ephemeral, this story will be housed exclusively at my site. (http://www.angelfire.com/ms/KtblleStorage/main.html) Thank you, Kat, for everything. Feedback: Feed me at supernova818@aol.com Author's Notes: Many thanks to Tori Amos for her song "A Sorta Fairytale" which played non-stop while I wrote this chapter. If you haven't heard it, well, you're missing out. Also, this chapter took longer to write than I had planned because of midterms and the flu (yuk!). I hope to post a new chapter once a week from now on. Hugs and thanks to Beach for beta. Much love to Snick. --------------- Sfumato ---------- Chapter 3 --------------- He finds her standing over Dara's corpse. The smell of death hangs heavy in the air; a bitter, metallic scent that invades his body and settles heavily in his stomach like bad wine. Some semblance of awareness makes its way into his shock-addled brain. "Scully, until we find out what's going on, maybe you shouldn't stand in front of the window," he says. She visibly startles at the sound of his voice. Mulder thinks he sees her nod, although she doesn't turn around to face him. Their earlier carelessness irritates him. Years ago they would have hit the floor first and asked questions later. Instinct would have taken precedence over emotion. He thinks they have been so long removed from the war that they have grown accustomed to being ruled by something other than fear. All in all not a bad trade, but he doesn't want their carelessness to rob them of everything they have worked so hard to attain. "Scully, I have a question," Mulder says. Slowly, he walks up behind her, lays his hands on her shoulders, and then turns her towards him and away from the carnage. She shrugs his hands away. "Scully, why do you think they let you go? Why after all this time?" "I don't know, Mulder. Two men came for me earlier today and tied me up, blindfolded me, and dropped me here," she replies. "I already told you that." "Something isn't adding up-" Mulder starts. "I assume they were finished running tests on me. Perhaps they'd found what they were looking for," she shrugs noncommittally. "Dara was a loose cannon waiting to go off. They probably didn't want to deal with the ramifications of who and what she was. She was created to serve an agenda and once she was finished, they were finished with her. No loose ends, no ties to them, and they'll get away with it as always." He doesn't have anything to say in response. Scully walks over to their shared walk-in closet. She stands in front of her clothes, gently letting her hands trail over tailored suits and a pair of threadbare jeans. "I suppose she wore my clothes," she laughs. It's not a question so he doesn't comment. Scully moves into the bathroom and slides her hands over the marble countertop. A hairdryer is precariously perched on the edge of the counter. Thigh highs are draped over the glass enclosed shower. A pair of black, Prada pumps is hiding in the corner. She remembers when she bought them. She and Mulder had taken the children to New York during Christmas break last year, so they could expose them to some culture, as she had put it to Mulder. Scully had seen the shoes in the window of the Prada store on Fifth Avenue. She'd gone inside the store, picked them up, and had fondled the smooth lines and curves of the very nearly perfect shoe. Mulder had cringed when he'd fondled the price tag. She'd mouthed "Armani suits" at him and he'd smiled. She'd happily marched to the counter and whipped out her credit card. There is nothing like a good pair of shoes. Later that day, Hope had begged to see a production of "Annie" that was playing Off-Off-Off Broadway. They all gave in; none of them could say no to Hope. After they returned home from New York, Hope had walked around the house for weeks singing "Tomorrow". It had been boys against girls as William and Mulder ganged up on her and tried to tickle her into promising she would stop singing the song. Scully had taken Hope's side and wrestled Mulder and William off Hope onto the floor. Hope had danced behind the couch and sung her heart out. That had been in January. She wondered whose side Dara took when she came into their lives. Scully slams her hands down on the countertop and whirls around to face him, "How could you think she was me?" she yells, pointing in the general direction of Dara's corpse. "How could you?" Reasonable explanations flutter through his mind, not sounding quite as reasonable when he sees the pain of his purported betrayal in Scully's eyes. "Scully, I thought something was wrong. We'd both been so busy with our respective cases that we'd hardly seen each other, and when we did, and you I mean she was acting strange, I chalked it up to tiredness or stress over the case. I did figure it out, though. I knew she wasn't you." "Took you long enough," she says under her breath. Anger fuels him and he rushes her so they are toe to toe, "You think this is easy for me? She's taken over your life, she's been playing mother to our children, she tricked me into bed!" Looking away from her, he sees his reflection in the bathroom mirror, fury shining brightly in his eyes. "I'm sorry for what atrocities I know you've suffered at the hands of these bastards, but you aren't the only one that has suffered, Scully; we've all suffered as a result of this." "You don't know the meaning of suffering," she says, leveling her gaze against his. "You don't know what it's like to come home after surviving hell and see your lover in bed with another woman. You don't know how I feel about missing even more of my son's life, and that another woman has been kissing my daughter goodnight." Like lightning striking, it comes back to her that he does know, at least to some extent. He was gone for months only to come back and find her enormously pregnant with their son; he left again, and their son was gone. She supposes that he can fathom how she feels, but anger and hurt combine to create a certain kind of destructive rage, and even as the next words leave her mouth, she knows she shouldn't say them. "Or maybe you've just forgotten. Maybe it's easier for you to forget so that you can live with it all. I can't forget, though." "Cruelty doesn't become you, Scully," he says and walks away. They've never talked about the aftermath of his miraculous resurrection. There were so many issues to face all those years ago, that everything surrounding his abduction was pushed to the backburner in favor of her safety and the safety of their child. Then Hope was born and they busied themselves with raising their two children and creating something resembling a normal life. Days have turned into years and they've still never found the words, but the emotions so long buried gurgle to the surface like lava, and finally it all boils over, unstoppable in its wrath. "That's right, Mulder. Walk away! You are so damn good at walking away. That's what you did after your abduction. You treated me like a second-class citizen and practically ran from me for months. I've forgotten how self-absorbed you can be. I'm still here, though, as always." "I could barely get close enough to you with John Doggett shadowing your every move, and you defending him at every given opportunity, and then there was Skinner with his whispered concern for you, Dana," he says, emphasizing her first name. "It seemed to me that you had more men in your life than you could handle. They may not have been in your bed, but they'd damn sure taken my place. I was bowing out gracefully and trying to allow you to make the decision that was right for you." "You were being a coward," she retorts. "I'm going to ignore that because if I reply it will definitely not be anything you want to hear." The muscles in his jaw twitch and he runs a hand through his hair. "Why in hell are we discussing this now?" "Because we've never talked about it. We shove everything under the proverbial rug, and go on without ever dealing with the ramifications of anything that has happened to us. I'm tired of turning the other cheek and pretending like I'm okay with people fucking with our lives. I'm so tired of being an instrument whereby evil men further their cause by violating me over and over again." Her voice peaks and then valleys. Emotions flicker across her face so quickly that he doesn't catch their meaning. Bile pushes its way up into his throat. "What are you saying, Scully? Did someone lay his hands on you in that way? Did one of those men force himself on you?" His earlier anger and frustration is gone. Now, there is only her and this moment, and those who have hurt her. He will kill them eventually; of that, he has no doubt. "Someone tried to but I rearranged his balls and he never touched me again," she says. Frustration and pain line her face; their marks even more apparent than her bruises. "They have violated me in the way that they have touched my body, tortured it, and taken from it without my consent. Violating someone isn't about sexual gratification; it's about power. They exert their power over me to the point that I am helpless. They have violated me for years, and I've gone on without saying much, but I'm tired of keeping it inside. I used to think if I kept it inside that you'd see me as your brave Scully, and that if I talked about it that you would see me as weak. Now I know that I didn't talk about it because I was weak; it takes more courage to face what they've done than to ignore it." Her hands come up to her face and she hides behind them as if embarrassed by her confession. He hangs his head as if ashamed that he's failed to acknowledge what they've been through. "They performed horrible tests, Mulder. It's not like with my first abduction; I remember everything this time." "What kinds of tests? What were they looking for?" he questions. "The were looking for that part of me that would save them. There was no part of me that was left untouched, Mulder. They examined every part of me and took samples of everything you could ever imagine and some things you probably won't want to. They even cut my damn nails," she laughs. The attempt at humor is gone, and suddenly she is very serious, a desperate edge to her voice, "Whatever it is they were looking for, I hope my body didn't betray me, and give it to them." She slides to the floor and the tears begin to fall. Mulder is by her side in an instant, and wraps his arms around her, murmuring comfort in her ear. She flinches when he rubs her back and he tells her not to be afraid and that he won't hurt her. She looks down to the floor and something like shame passes across her face. He can't describe the way it changes her, only that it has, and he hates with renewed passion what these men have done to her, to all of them. He rubs his hands over her back again, testing to see if it's his touch or pain that causes her to shy away from him. Her eyes are closed and her mouth is clamped shut when she hisses as a result of what is definitely physical pain. He tips her head up towards him and tells her to open her eyes. He promises not to hurt her, but that he has to check her injuries. She closes her eyes again and nods her head in assent. She's wearing blue scrubs, and so there is no way to check her injuries but to remove the scrub shirt, which will leave her completely bare to him. He gets up and grabs one of his t-shirts off a hanger in the closet. He hands it to her with the hope that she will retain some semblance of control over the situation. She clutches it to her chest like a dying man would the Bible on his deathbed. "I'm going to take this shirt off now, Scully," he says. Her only acknowledgement to his having spoken is when she gently lays his t-shirt in her lap. Slowly, he begins to remove the over-sized top portion of the scrub ensemble over her head. When it is completely off, she clutches his t-shirt to her breasts, covering them from view. "Shit," he says. Her back is a rainbow of old and new bruises. The bottoms of the scrubs hang low on her hips, obviously too large for her small frame, a square, raw patch of skin peeks up from the waistband. He can't even imagine what they did that would leave behind such an angry wound. There are five, small, oval marks on the inside of each of her biceps. "What the hell is this, Scully?" he asks, not wanting to think about the implications. "I never stopped fighting, Mulder," she says and then she is in his arms again, and her small, bruised body has never felt so good. "Sometimes they'd give me a mild sedative before the tests, to make me more compliant, but I always fought, Mulder. I didn't want to help them. They've taken so much from us, I didn't want to help them take more," she says. "Who did this to you," he says quietly. She doesn't answer because she can't. They were faces that smiled at her pain, bodies that moved in sterile rooms as she screamed, and strong arms that held her down when she fought. They were men who beat her when she resisted. They were the bitter laughter in her ears after they sanctimoniously informed her time and time again that Mulder wasn't looking for her. She shakes her head and is startled when Mulder wrenches away from her. "Who did this to you?" he yells. She is afraid for him, not of him, when she sees the look in his eyes. She knows that look. He won't rest until he finds out who did this to her. She's seen it before, but not for a long time. She knows that his justice will, in his mind, exorcise whatever guilt he may have in regard to this whole situation. Avenging the victim is easier than dealing with the pain. "I don't know, Mulder," she answers. "Do you think you could remember where they kept you? Do you know where they were keeping you?" "No," she replies solemnly. "Damn it!" he yells and half-heartedly punches the wall. Quietly, Scully rises to her feet, still clutching Mulder's t-shirt to her breasts, and makes her way to his side of their shared closet. She pulls a loose fitting long-sleeved shirt off its hanger and exits the bedroom without a word. Mulder hears a door open and close in the hall signaling she is making use of their guest bathroom for the evening. He looks over at Dara; her eyes are wide open, and her lips are blue. Some unknown verbal exchange will remain forever on the tip of her tongue. Despite the hatred he feels for this dead woman, he doesn't want to bury her. She looks too much like Scully. He supposes this is his punishment for failing to realize sooner that she wasn't. -X- "Hope, wake up!" William murmurs frantically. William gets out of his bed, walks to the edge of Hope's bed, and tries to rouse his sister. He gently shakes her but she is caught in the clutches of her nightmare and continues to alternately whimper and cry out. William begins to shake her more insistently, begging her away from whatever it is that frightens her, prodding her to awaken. Finally, her eyes open, and William's body goes slack in relief. "What was that all about, Hope?" Before she can answer, Skinner stumbles into their room, squinting his eyes, and mumbles, "what's wrong?" "She just had a nightmare, Mr. Skinner. She's okay now." "You sure?" Skinner questions. "Yeah, she's okay now," William assures. Skinner stumbles out the way he entered. William turns back to his sister, the look on her face causing his small body to tense. "You okay, short stuff?" William asks. "It's the same dream, Will," she says, grasping his hand. "The one about running?" "Yeah, that one," she says. Damp, brown curls frame her face, and she trembles as the remnants of her dream fade away. "It's okay, Hope. Everything will be okay," William says. He pushes on her shoulder and she scoots over on the bed. William lies down beside her. "Will you tell me a story," she asks. William is practicing to be as good a storyteller as his father. Hope is always a more than willing audience to his tales of heroes and far away galaxies. "Which one?" William asks, yawning. "Anything," Hope answers, mirroring William's yawn. William ruminates for a few moments, mentally flipping through the stories in his mind, and then decides on the one he knows to be her favorite. Hope turns on her side, facing him, and closes her eyes. "There was once a little girl named Emily and because evil men wanted to steal her beauty, she traveled to a faraway place called Heaven, where she would be beautiful forever. She was so sad she had to leave planet earth, though, that she developed a magic passageway so she could visit earth whenever she was lonely. It was perfect because only she could travel in the passageway: no bad guys allowed," William pauses and looks over to Hope who has already fallen asleep. He is tired and it is becoming harder for him to keep his eyes open, but he continues telling the story, and doesn't stop until he comes to the end, where everyone lives happily ever after. -X- He remembers back to the early years of their partnership, an encounter in a warehouse, where Scully shot herself in the head. It wasn't her then either, he laughs without humor, but he remembers being completely off kilter for weeks in the wake of seeing her drop dead on a concrete floor. If he thought that was a nightmare, then this must be hell. His palms are blistered from the continuous friction of the shovel against his hands as he dug into the earth. She looked so much like Scully. Upon entering their house, he becomes aware immediately, of the absolute quietness. He begins searching for Scully. As he goes from room to room only to discover the emptiness it contains, he begins to feel alarmed. "Scully!" he calls out. "I'm in the office," he hears faintly. He takes the stairs two at a time and finds her sitting at his desk. "Is it done?" she asks. "Yeah," he answers. "Any problems on the home front while I was gone?" "No," she says. "I don't expect there to be any either. I assume they've finished playing doctor. At least for the time being." Quietly, she pushes a legal pad across the desk. She puts a finger to her lips and glances up and around, indicating she thinks the house might be bugged. Nodding, he turns the yellow legal pad over. After he's finished reading her request, he looks up at her in disbelief, and somberly nods his head. She holds up a paper bag and rises from her position behind the desk. He notices that she has dressed in anticipation of his compliance. He opens the back door, and gestures for her to go ahead of him. Scully steps out onto the deck, and Mulder closes the door behind him as he joins her outside. They begin to make their way into the woods behind the house. Mulder drapes his arm around her shoulders and she does not pull away. -X- He breaks open the pen and allows the ink to spill into the container. She holds a flashlight in her hand, shining the light down on him. "Are you sure about this, Scully?" "Yes," is all she says. He uncaps the needle and dips it into the ink. She bends her neck to the left and brushes the hair away from her face. "Right here," she says, pointing to a place right at her hairline. She hands him the penlight and he puts it into his mouth, holding it in place with his teeth. He palms the needle and soaks a cotton ball in alcohol. She shivers when he brushes it across her skin. He brings his hand up to her nape. The needle is poised at her hairline. Blue ink shines on its tip. He tells her it might hurt. She already knows it will. She's been marked before, although that was done in a moment of recklessness, and has since been removed. She knows this mark will be forever. The needle bites into her flesh like a thousand little teeth. Pain subsides for a moment. He dips the needle into the makeshift inkwell and the needle sinks its teeth into her again. They are not married in the eyes of the law. There has never been a ceremony. Their marriage has been born, like a child, brought into being by anguished cries, and then realized in secret moments, and finally an embraced happiness. No rings have ever been worn, or for that matter, offered. He asked once if she wanted them to be married, after Hope was born, and she said it wasn't necessary. He never brought it up again. As the pain ebbs and flows, she thinks there should be a fire, with tribal men dancing around, indicative of some kind of primitive marriage ritual. Warm hands caress her neck. She's dreamt about them for the past month. When he is finished, he stares at his handiwork. "It's done," he whispers in her ear. "I tried to make it blend in like you said, Scully." To anyone else it might look like a vein: something necessary that carries blood to her heart. She supposes his mark is somewhat like that. He is like that to her. Necessary. Vital. A small blue line, less than an inch long throbs beneath a veil of auburn hair. No one can copy this. Her scars are available for the entire world to see, but this mark, will remain their secret. "I'm sorry I hurt you," he says. "I know you are," she sighs. "You know there were other women before you," he says, drawing in a breath. "But Scully, I spent my life looking for you, that's why nothing ever lasted. I knew there was something better out there for me. I wasn't sure I'd ever find it, but I knew it was out there, waiting for me. What I'm trying to say is that you are it for me. There were other women before you, but there will never be a woman after you. No one could ever measure up, baby. And this whole thing with Dara, even though I didn't know, it was wrong, and I'm sorry that I've hurt you." She melts into him. "You are my soul mate, Scully." He brushes the hair away from her ear, finding his mark, and places a whisper of a kiss atop it. A sob breaks loose and shatters the quiet that surrounds them. A hundred different variations of "I'm sorry" fall from his lips. She takes them all in the palm of her hand, and presses kisses to each and every one. Pulling away, she turns in the direction of their house, and begins to walk the short distance home. He stands in place, the remnants of a primitive ceremony, scattered around him. She stops, her back to him, and holds out her hand. He gathers up the bits and pieces of their ceremony and rushes to her side. Forgiveness is found in a tangle of fingers. They arrive home within a few minutes, and as they stand together on the deck, Scully says she wants some time alone. Mulder nods and tells her he's going to clean up their bedroom. The back door shuts softly behind him, leaving her feeling slightly vulnerable, and beyond lonely. She needs this time, though, to regain her footing. A cast iron chimenea is nestled in the corner of the deck. Scully remembers it fondly; she and Mulder curled up on the built in seats of their low deck, the chimenea giving off warmth on an otherwise cold Bangor night. They would look up at the stars, and being in each other's arms made those stars beautiful again. Scully lifts the lid of a sturdy wooden box and retrieves the long stemmed matches it contains. She walks to the back door and opens the brown, paper bag Mulder dropped before going inside. Finding the yellow legal pad that has settled to the bottom, she tears off the first few sheets of paper and throws them into the chimenea. Upon striking the match, an eerie orange glow throws off color in the otherwise murky night. The match lands silently on top of the paper, and slowly, it all begins to burn. Yellow pieces of paper writhe as the fire begins to eat at it. Her words turn to face her, one last time, before being consumed: You've got to do this, Mulder. I never want you to doubt who I am again. I want you to always know it's me. Finally, the fire has its way, yellow is turned to black, and her words are ashes. She goes inside long enough to dispose of the bag and its contents. She shoves it under a rind of a cantaloupe and expired loaf of French bread. After her task is complete, she goes back outside, and watches as the fire begins to tease its way up the side of a partially charcoaled piece of wood. It's a cold night, and so she wraps her arms around her body, Mulder's shirt not an entirely appropriate barrier against the elements. Pulling the sleeves down, she covers the marks on her wrists. She's practicing for tomorrow. She doesn't want to frighten her children. Make-up, she hopes, will cover most of the bruising on her face. Leaves rustle to her left, and suddenly she senses that she isn't alone. A man begins to appear from the shadows, and the knot in her stomach grows tighter when she realizes she recognizes him. It's the man that has haunted her for the past month; the man who laughed at her helplessness; the man whose fists bruised her face. "Jesus, there you are, Dara. I've been staking out the place for the last half hour! Where the hell have you been, and why aren't you answering your fucking phone?" Scully is frozen in place, rendered speechless, completely helpless without a way to defend herself. She already knows he is much stronger than she. "I'm sorry," she says. Immediately, her hands go to her face, trying to cover the bruising there. She hopes the darkness will serve her well, at least for a few moments. She hopes he doesn't notice the way her voice hitches with each syllable. "What are you doing here?" "Well, haven't I got a story for you. Seems like Dana had a fucking Good Samaritan after all. Four motherfuckers broke into the lab earlier and stole her right out from under our fucking noses. Sebastian has everyone out looking for her. You need to make up an excuse for lover boy and come with me. Sebastian wants to see you. Plans have changed, Dara." "I can't leave right now," Scully says. She pulls at the sleeves of her shirt and pins the edges between her palm and the tips of her fingers. "Don't be a fucking bitch about it, Dara. The boss wants to see you, now come on," he says. Scully barely has time to register that he's moved, and before she can even react, he's got her by the arm, and is dragging her around the side of the house towards a dark colored sedan. "What do you think you're doing?" She's surprised at how calm his voice is. The man holding her arm falters and turns around at the sound of Mulder's voice. The man looks to Scully and realization dawns. A break in the trees allows moonlight to filter through, and as pale light illuminates her face, it also reveals her bruises. Dara doesn't have bruises, but Dana does. She can almost hear the thought circulate through his brain. "What the fuck?" he says, and his grip on her arm becomes tighter. Mulder has his gun out from behind his back and is pointing it at the man before Scully has time to blink. "I'm going to count to three and you're going to release her, or I'm going to blow your head off," Mulder says. His arm doesn't falter and neither does his voice. He begins walking toward them, "One, two-" Scully feels herself being pushed toward Mulder as the man that held her begins to run. Mulder catches her in his arms, and says "Stop, or I'll shoot you in the fucking back you coward", and the man stops, his arms raised above his head. Scully stands off to the side fairly shocked at the recent turn of events. Mulder is busy dragging her tormentor towards the woods. Scully runs to catch up, and as she comes closer, she hears Mulder asking the man a question. "Are you the one that hurt her?" he asks. The man stands stone silent and is visibly afraid. Mulder backhands him and the man drops to his knees. "Did you hear what I said you son of a bitch?" Mulder yells. "Mulder-" Scully starts. Mulder turns his head slightly to look at her. In his peripheral vision, he watches the man now bleeding heavily from his lower lip. Mulder keeps his gun trained on the man directly in front of him, and brings his hand to Scully's face. "Did he do this to you? Is he the one that hurt you so badly?" His hand is so gentle against her bruised flesh. "Scully, did he do this to you?" Mulder asks more insistently. Her shaky exhale is the only answer he needs. Positioning Scully behind him, he raises himself up to his full height. Broad shoulders, muscles defined from working in the yard and running every morning, resolve steeled from so many years of loving Scully. "Stand up you piece of shit," Mulder says. His hand falls away from Scully's face; the hand holding the gun is steady and trained on its target. He stares at the man now standing before him. "You took Scully away from me. You took away the person I love most in the world, the person who has been faithful to me in spite of myself, and you made me betray her by putting someone else in my bed. You took her away from our children. You tortured and beat her; you bruised her beautiful face. You have robbed us of memories we can never get back, you have robbed us of happiness, you have robbed us of the peace we have fought so long to have," Mulder pauses, his free hand fisting at his side, "and now you are going to pay for it all." Continued in Chapter 4